The NHL regular season is drawing to a close, and with it, the opportunity to reflect on the standout performances of the 2025-26 season. The Athletic has asked its NHL staff to identify the MVP and most disappointing player for each team, providing a comprehensive overview of the league's top performers and areas of concern.
MVPs and Disappointments
The MVPs and disappointments were selected based on a variety of factors, including individual performance, team success, and overall impact. Here's a breakdown of the top performers and underperforming players for each team:
MVPs
Nathan MacKinnon (Colorado Avalanche): MacKinnon's dominance on the ice is undeniable. He's on pace to eclipse the 100-point mark for the fourth consecutive season, showcasing his exceptional playmaking and scoring abilities. His performance has been a cornerstone for the Avalanche's success.
Jack Hughes (New Jersey Devils): Hughes' impact on the Devils' season cannot be overstated. When healthy, he's one of the most dynamic players in the NHL, leading the team in points and goals. His ability to drive the team's offense is crucial.
Mika Zibanejad (New York Rangers): Zibanejad's resurgence this season has been remarkable. After a disappointing 2024-25 campaign, he's bounced back, leading the Rangers in scoring and providing a consistent threat on the ice.
Erik Karlsson (Pittsburgh Penguins): Karlsson's all-around brilliance has been a key factor in the Penguins' playoff success. His defensive prowess and offensive contributions have elevated the team's performance.
Nikita Kucherov (Tampa Bay Lightning): Kucherov's offensive prowess is unparalleled. His game-changing abilities, playmaking, and scoring have made him a front-runner for the Hart Trophy, solidifying his status as one of the league's most valuable players.
Most Disappointing Players
Jack Drury (Colorado Avalanche): Drury's struggle to develop into an offensive threat has been a concern. Despite his potential, he's only managed a modest number of points, falling short of expectations.
Ondřej Palát (New Jersey Devils): Palát's production dipped significantly this season, and his trade to the Islanders highlights the team's struggle to find a suitable role for him.
Ville Koivunen (Pittsburgh Penguins): Koivunen's inability to find his game has been a disappointment. His lack of offensive impact and frequent time in the AHL have raised questions about his development.
Gustav Nyquist (Winnipeg Jets): Nyquist's performance has fallen short of expectations, with a minimal number of goals and points. His $3.25 million AAV contract has been a point of contention.
Tomáš Hertl (Vegas Golden Knights): Hertl's struggle to drive offense at five-on-five has been a concern. His minus-16 on-ice rating is a stark reminder of his underperformance compared to expectations.
